CarMax vs Carvana at a Glance

Both companies publish their policies. Every row below comes from CarMax's and Carvana's own pages, and the sources are listed at the end of this article.

If you're buying

TopicCarMaxCarvana
Can you negotiate the price?No. CarMax says its "upfront prices are set."No. Carvana says "We don't negotiate on pricing" and that it never adds "any dealer charges."
Test driveYes, at any CarMax store, by appointment online or by phone. If you buy online, you can test drive at your express pickup appointment.A short test spin during your pickup appointment. After that, the 7-Day Money Back Guarantee is your evaluation period.
Return window10-day money back guarantee. Return the car to the store where you bought it, as long as its condition is consistent with when you bought it.7-Day Money Back Guarantee from the day you receive the car. Up to 400 miles, then $1.00 per additional mile. You must notify Carvana before 8:00 p.m. EST on the 7th day.
Included limited warranty30 days. In NJ and NY, 90 days or 4,000 miles, whichever comes first.100 days or 4,189 miles, whichever comes first.
Optional extended coverageMaxCare, which CarMax describes as entirely optional. It can only be bought with the car.Optional protection plans, offered during the purchase.
Ways to payCarMax financing, your own bank or credit union, or cash. Credit cards can't be used, including for down payments.Carvana financing, cash, or an approved bank or credit union.
Getting the carExpress pickup at a CarMax store, or delivery within 60 miles of its stores in select markets. A car moved from another store may carry a shipping fee, which is nonrefundable.Pickup at a Carvana location or Car Vending Machine, or delivery, for which a delivery charge may be added. Some cars carry a shipping charge, which is not refundable.

If you're selling (or trading in)

TopicCarMaxCarvana
Can you negotiate the offer?No. CarMax says "all of our offers are firm and valid for 7 days."No. Carvana says "We do not price match or negotiate our offers."
How long the offer lasts7 days, online or in-store.7 days.
What the offer is based onThe car's year, make, model, mileage and features, its condition, history and use, and market conditions, CarMax says.The vehicle details and condition you submit. Carvana says its offers "vary over time to reflect current auto market conditions and values."
Can the offer change at inspection?CarMax adjusts an online offer only if the car's condition, use or history differs from what you reported.Not at your appointment if your information was accurate. If Carvana's checks or the final confirmation find a mismatch, it generates an updated offer.
After the 7 daysCarMax re-appraises the car and gives you an updated offer.Resubmitting gets you a new offer, which Carvana says "could result in a higher or lower appraisal amount."
Handing over the carAt any CarMax store within 7 days, with or without an appointment. Most locations can pick the car up from your home or work. CarMax says distance restrictions and a fee may apply.Pickup where it's available, or drop-off at a Carvana hub or vending machine. Carvana says a pickup fee may apply, and you'll see it before you schedule.
How and when you're paidThe same day you sell, by bank draft. It must be deposited and cannot be cashed.At the pickup or drop-off appointment, by printed check or ACH. Carvana says ACH direct deposit normally takes one to two business days to process, and ACH transfers two to five.
If you still owe on the carIf you owe more than the offer, you pay CarMax the difference, or in some cases include it in CarMax financing when you buy a CarMax car.Carvana pays off your loan after the sale. If the car is worth more than you owe, you receive the difference.
Do you have to buy from them?No. CarMax says its offer is the same whether you buy from it or not.No.

Policies as published by CarMax and Carvana, checked October 2026. Confirm current terms with each company before you decide.

Are CarMax and Carvana the same company? No. CarMax, Inc. (NYSE: KMX, based in Richmond, Virginia) and Carvana Co. (NYSE: CVNA, based in Tempe, Arizona) are separate public companies that each file their own reports with the SEC.

Buying From CarMax vs Carvana

Neither company negotiates on price, so the real differences are how you get to know the car and what happens if it isn't right.

  • Test drive before or after you commit. At CarMax you can test drive at any store before you buy. At Carvana, the drive is a short test spin at pickup, and the 7-Day Money Back Guarantee is the time you have to live with the car.
  • Return window. CarMax's money back guarantee runs 10 days. Carvana's runs 7 days from the day you receive the car, with a 400-mile limit and $1.00 for each mile over it. Both say shipping charges are nonrefundable.
  • Included warranty. Carvana's limited warranty runs longer: 100 days or 4,189 miles, against CarMax's 30 days (90 days or 4,000 miles in NJ and NY). Both offer optional extended coverage at purchase, and CarMax says MaxCare can't be added after the sale.

Selling to CarMax vs Carvana

Both make a firm offer that lasts 7 days, and neither requires you to buy a car from it. The differences are in how you hand over the car and how you are paid.

  • Getting the car to them. CarMax takes the car at any store within 7 days, and most locations can pick it up from your home or work. Carvana offers pickup in many areas, so you may never leave your house. Availability depends on your location, a pickup fee may apply, and drop-off at a Carvana location avoids it.
  • Getting paid. CarMax says you leave with payment in hand the day you sell, by bank draft (it must be deposited and cannot be cashed). Carvana pays at the pickup or drop-off appointment, by printed check or ACH.
  • Offer changes. The online offer holds only if your information was accurate. Carvana checks the car at the pickup appointment, and if something doesn't match what you reported, it generates an updated offer. Our guide on Carvana offer changes covers exactly how this happens and how to prevent it. CarMax likewise adjusts an online offer only if the car's condition, use or history differs from what you reported.
  • Negotiation. Like Carvana, CarMax does not negotiate. Their offer is their offer. See our breakdown on whether you can negotiate with Carvana.
  • Loans. Carvana handles lien payoffs directly with your lender. At CarMax, if you owe more than the offer, you pay the difference, and CarMax says its 7-day offer gives you time to gather the funds.

One public record is worth knowing. Title and registration delays have been a documented issue at Carvana, including a settlement with the Connecticut Attorney General that also covered delayed payments to sellers.

Which Should You Choose?

  • Buying, and you want to drive the car before you commit: CarMax, with a store test drive and a 10-day money back guarantee.
  • Buying online, and you want the longer included warranty: Carvana, with 100 days or 4,189 miles of limited warranty and a 7-Day Money Back Guarantee.
  • Selling, and you want to be paid today: CarMax. CarMax pays the same day by bank draft. Describe your car accurately and an online offer should hold at verification.
  • Selling, and you do not want to leave home: Carvana, where pickup is available, but go in with realistic expectations about offer adjustments and payment timing.
  • Not sure: get offers from both. Each is valid for 7 days, and neither requires you to buy from it.

Want Another Number to Compare?

CarMax and Carvana each set their own price and make their own offer. If you want another number before you decide, Vantage Motor Car buys cars from sellers and takes trade-ins.

Selling or trading in? You can see how that works on our pages for selling a car in New Jersey or selling a car in the New York metro area, or start your trade. If you already have a CarMax or Carvana offer, compare my offer.

Sources: CarMax, Sell My Car and FAQ (selling, buying, test drive, warranties, delivery and payment answers); Carvana Help Center: pricing, pickup and test spin, 7-Day Money Back Guarantee, warranty, financing, delivery, negotiating offers, offer changes, pickup, pickup and drop-off, payment, selling with a loan; SEC EDGAR filer records for CarMax, Inc. and Carvana Co.; Connecticut Attorney General, Carvana settlement (January 14, 2025).

Frequently Asked Questions

Is CarMax or Carvana better for selling a car?

Neither is consistently better. Both make offers that are valid for 7 days, and neither negotiates them. CarMax adjusts an online offer only if the car's condition, use, or history differs from what you reported, and Carvana says your offer will not change at your appointment if your information was accurate. Carvana offers pickup where available (a fee may apply), and CarMax pays the same day by bank draft. The best approach is to get offers from both and compare the final numbers.

Is it better to buy a car from CarMax or Carvana?

It depends on how you want to buy. Neither negotiates on price. CarMax lets you test drive at a store first and gives you a 10-day money back guarantee. Carvana sells online and includes the longer limited warranty, 100 days or 4,189 miles, with a 7-Day Money Back Guarantee of up to 400 miles. CarMax's limited warranty is 30 days, or 90 days or 4,000 miles in NJ and NY.

Which has a better return policy, CarMax or Carvana?

CarMax gives you longer. Its 10-day money back guarantee lets you return the car to the store where you bought it, as long as its condition is consistent with when you bought it. Carvana's 7-Day Money Back Guarantee starts the day you receive the car and covers up to 400 miles, then $1.00 per additional mile. Both say shipping charges are nonrefundable.

Are CarMax and Carvana the same company?

No. CarMax, Inc. (NYSE: KMX, based in Richmond, Virginia) and Carvana Co. (NYSE: CVNA, based in Tempe, Arizona) are separate public companies that each file their own reports with the SEC.

Does CarMax negotiate on their offer?

No. Like Carvana, CarMax uses a no-negotiation model. Their appraisal is their offer, and you either accept or decline. CarMax says all of its offers, online and in-store, are firm and valid for 7 days, and it adjusts an online offer only if the car's condition, use, or history differs from the information you provided.

How long does it take to sell to CarMax vs Carvana?

CarMax can complete a sale the same day, including payment: it pays with a bank draft, and you leave with it the day you sell. Carvana's process starts online, and Carvana pays at your pickup or drop-off appointment, by printed check or ACH. Carvana says ACH direct deposit normally takes one to two business days to process, and ACH transfers two to five.

Which option gets you the most money for your car?

No single option wins every time. A private sale can bring a higher price but takes the most effort. CarMax and Carvana are convenient, but each gives you one offer from one buyer. The practical answer is to collect offers from at least two sources before deciding.

What is a car broker and how is it different from Carvana or CarMax?

A car broker helps you gather more than one offer for your car, rather than making you a single offer. Carvana and CarMax are each one buyer with one price.

Keep Reading

More on buying, selling and trading a car.