It Depends on Your Lease Company

CarMax can buy leased vehicles, but only when the leasing company allows third-party buyouts. Since 2021, several major captive finance companies have restricted this option. Before you drive anywhere, call your leasing company and ask directly: is my vehicle eligible for a third-party purchase?

Which Lenders Allow or Restrict Third-Party Buyouts?

Policies change, but here is the general picture as of 2026:

  • Toyota Financial Services: restricted in most states
  • Honda Financial Services: restricted
  • Subaru Motors Finance: restricted
  • BMW Financial Services: generally permitted
  • GM Financial (Chevrolet, GMC, Cadillac): generally permitted
  • Ford Credit: generally permitted
  • Chrysler Capital / Stellantis: check current policy

This list is not exhaustive and policies change without notice. Calling your leasing company directly is the only reliable way to confirm.

How the Process Works When Eligible

If your lease company allows it, here is what happens at CarMax: they inspect the car and generate an offer, then contact your leasing company to confirm the residual. If their offer exceeds the residual, they pay off the lease and cut you a check for the difference. If the offer equals the residual, you exit the lease at no cost. If the offer is below the residual, they will not complete the purchase. Plan on two to four hours in the store.

What If CarMax's Offer Is Below the Residual?

Get more quotes. CarMax sets prices on their own inventory model, which may not reflect what other buyers would pay. Try Carvana for a second instant quote or visit a franchise dealer in your brand. The spread between a single CarMax offer and what multiple buyers return can be significant, particularly on trucks and SUVs that hold value well.

For the full picture on leased car selling options, read our post on how to sell a leased car and capture equity.

What If Third-Party Buyouts Are Restricted?

Your options narrow to: buy the car yourself at the residual, take title, and then sell as a used vehicle; or return the car at lease end. Buying out first triggers sales tax in NJ (6.625%), which can eat into any equity. Run the full math before committing to a self-buyout strategy.

Getting the Most From Any Offer

Get at least three or four quotes before deciding. CarMax, Carvana, a local dealer in your brand, and Vantage Motor Car. The spread on identical vehicles across buyers can be thousands or more, and that difference is the equity you capture.

You can get a Vantage Motor Car offer here to add to your comparison. If the lease equity math works in your favor, competing offers give you the best shot at capturing it fully.

Frequently Asked Questions

Will CarMax buy my leased car?

It depends on your lease company. CarMax can purchase leased vehicles when the leasing company allows third-party buyouts. However, several major manufacturers' finance arms, including Toyota Financial Services, have restricted or eliminated third-party buyouts. The safest way to find out is to call your leasing company directly and ask if your vehicle is eligible for third-party purchase.

How does selling a leased car to CarMax work?

If your lease allows it, you bring the car to CarMax for an appraisal. CarMax contacts your leasing company to get the payoff amount and compares it to their offer. If their offer exceeds the payoff, you receive the difference as a check. If it does not, CarMax typically will not complete the purchase unless you cover the gap. The process usually takes a few hours.

Do I need to buy out my lease before CarMax can buy it?

Not always. If your leasing company allows third-party buyouts, CarMax can work directly with them without you buying the car first. However, if third-party buyouts are restricted, you would need to exercise your purchase option first, obtain the title, and then sell the car to CarMax as a used vehicle. Check with your leasing company before visiting CarMax.

What if CarMax's offer is less than my lease buyout price?

If CarMax's appraisal comes in below your lease buyout price, they will typically decline the purchase. At that point, your options are to cover the difference out of pocket, get quotes from other buyers like Carvana or a local dealer, or simply return the car at lease end. Do not assume one offer reflects the market; getting three quotes is always worth the time.

Can any dealer buy my leased car, not just CarMax?

Yes, many franchised dealers and used-car retailers will appraise and potentially buy leased vehicles if the leasing company permits it. Franchise dealers that sell your brand (like a Toyota dealer for a Toyota lease) often have more flexibility since they maintain direct relationships with the captive finance company. Getting multiple dealer offers alongside CarMax and Carvana is the best way to maximize your result.

Keep Reading

More on buying, selling and trading a car.