If CarMax's appraisal comes in below your lease buyout price, the difference is negative equity. CarMax says you can pay CarMax the difference directly, and its offers are valid for 7 days to give you time to gather the funds. Your other options are to get quotes from other buyers like Carvana or a local dealer, or simply return the car at lease end. Do not assume one offer reflects the market; getting three quotes is always worth the time.